Preview Mode Links will not work in preview mode

Dec 23, 2018

“Toh-boo always wants to be with me…” In this HOLIDAY SPECIAL, a young girl calls the Carroll Sisters with questions about her new toy, a Furby with abandonment issues. Meg talks about cursed objects. MK tries to define consciousness.


Dec 18, 2018

“I’ve tried to put this ghost crap behind me…” In this MID-SEASON FINALE, for the first time in over a decade, the Carroll Sisters hear from Adam. He grew up next door in the Murder House and survived the fire that burnt it down--but that wasn’t the end of his horror story. Strange troubles follow Adam...


Dec 11, 2018

“At first, she was just a shape in the dark…” A childhood friend reaches out to the Carroll Sisters with a disturbing story that raises new questions about the Murder House, John Dearborn, and someone else from their past. In addition, Meg explains Merlin’s demonic origins. MK talks about the deadly side of...


Dec 4, 2018

“Then came the gunshot…” While tracking a poacher through the snow, this Pennsylvania park ranger may have stumbled upon an urban legend’s hunting ground. Meg and MK recount their own scary and stupid misadventure in the Jersey Pine Barrens.

WARNING: Episode may contain mentions of violence or trauma. Listener...


Nov 27, 2018

“Then she just ripped me out of bed…” On Halloween night in 1977, she snuck out to see her boyfriend. The next day he was murdered by his father, John Dearborn. This episode is about the Dearborn family and who they were before the killings, as told by some of the people who knew them. The Carroll sisters try to...